MacroXray logoMACROXRAY
Products
OptimizeCraveBenchmark
HomeProductsProtein BarOverload Protein Bar, Cookie Commotion
← Back to Protein Bar
Quest Nutrition

Overload Protein Bar, Cookie Commotion

Cookie commotion · Whey Protein Isolate, Casein, Milk Protein Isolate · 58g serving

#123in Protein Bar(433)
✓ Gluten-Free✓ Vegetarian✓ Kosher
1/3
XRay Score
66/100
Performance
P/kcal$P:F▾ CFb
At-a-Glance
20g
Protein /serving
11g
Fiber /serving
200
kcal /serving
10.0g
Protein /100kcal
Performance
ProteinEfficiencyValue forMoneyLeannessLow CarbFiber
Where to Buy
iHerbBest value
12 count · 12 servings
US$3.64/serving
US$43.69 for pack
Buy Now
Ships Worldwide
🇺🇸 Prices in USD
View more buying options

XRay Summary

  • Ranks #123 of 433 · XRay Score 66/100
  • Strength: Low Carb (Top 14%)
  • Weakness: Value For Money (Bottom 68%)
  • Protein Source: Milk Blend
  • Flavor: Sweet
  • Dietary: Kosher Certified And Gluten-Free

Overload Protein Bar, Cookie Commotion by Quest Nutrition sits comfortably in the upper half in the protein bar category with an XRay Score of 66/100, placing #123 out of 433. Its strongest dimension is low carb (top 14%), keeping carbohydrates minimal. On the flip side, price-to-protein ratio trails competitors (bottom 68% of the category). It uses a milk protein blend, offering both fast- and slow-release amino acids. On the flavor front, expect sweet tones. It should also be noted that this product is Kosher certified and gluten-free.

How It Ranks

Ranked against 433 products in this category.

XRay Score5D weighted score across all dimensions
#123 of 433
66/100XRay Score
Protein Efficiencygrams of protein per 100 kcal — higher is better
#76 of 433
10.0g/100kcal20.0g/serving83rd percentile
Value for Moneygrams of protein per unit of currency — higher is better
#271 of 401
5.49 g/US$33rd percentile
Leannessprotein-to-fat ratio — higher is better
#166 of 419
2.2:161st percentile
Low Carbnet carbs per 100g — lower is better
#55 of 379
17.2g/100g10.0g/serving86th percentile
Fiberfiber per 100g — higher is better
#64 of 366
19.0g/100g11.0g/serving83rd percentile

Leaderboard

XRay Score — Protein Bar (433 products)

RankProductProtein Eff.g/100kcalScore/100
#1
David Protein Bar, Cake Batter
David Protein Bar, Cake Batter
David
18.7g/100kcal97
···
#121
Per4m Chocolate Peanut Butter Flavour Protein Bar
Per4m Chocolate Peanut Butter Flavour Protein Bar
Per4m
10.0g/100kcal66
#122
Crispy Snack Bars, Variety Pack
Crispy Snack Bars, Variety Pack
Simply Protein
8.7g/100kcal66
#123
Overload Protein Bar, Cookie Commotion
Overload Protein Bar, Cookie Commotion
Quest Nutrition
10.0g/100kcal66
#124
Smart Protein Bar (Birthday Cake)
Smart Protein Bar (Birthday Cake)
PhD
7.7g/100kcal66
#125
Protein Bar (Mint Chocolate Crisp)
Protein Bar (Mint Chocolate Crisp)
Barebells
9.5g/100kcal66
See all 433 ranked →

Performance

Visual comparison across the 5 dimensions and macronutrient split.

Radar

How this product compares on each dimension — overlaid on the category median (gray). Larger area is always better. Hover any label for raw values and formula.

ProteinEfficiencyValue forMoneyLeannessLow CarbFiber
This productAverage Protein Bar(n=433)
Learn more about our methodology →

Macro Split

200kcal/serving
Protein
33%
Fat
33%
Carbs
34%

Nutrition

Macronutrient breakdown and product details.

NutrientPer Serving (58g)Per 100g
Energy200kcal344.83kcal
Protein20g34.48g
Total Fat9g15.52g
Sat. Fat6g10.34g
Carbohydrates21g36.21g
Fiber11g18.97g
Sugar1g1.72g
Sodium220mg379.31mg

Shop

Best prices across retailers — shown in your selected currency.

ProductRetailerPricePer ServingShips to
12 count696g · 12 sv
Best Value
iHerb
Worldwide
US$43.69
US$3.64/sv
Buy Now
12 count696g · 12 servings
iHerb
Best Value
US$43.69
US$3.64/serving
Worldwide
Buy
Prices shown in each retailer's original currency. Shipping availability and delivery to your country depend on the retailer.

Disclaimer — All nutritional data and product information is provided to the best of our knowledge based on publicly available sources and may contain inaccuracies. MacroXray is not responsible for discrepancies between listed and actual product data. Nothing on this site constitutes medical, dietary, or nutritional advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making changes to your diet. Dietary restriction labels (e.g. gluten-free, vegan) are based on ingredient information and may not account for cross-contamination or manufacturing processes — always verify with the manufacturer if you have allergies or intolerances. Halal, Kosher and other certifications shown are based on product labeling or third party site descriptions; actual certification status may vary by region and should be confirmed with the certifying body or manufacturer. Prices shown are sourced from third-party retailers at the time of last scan and may have changed since then. MacroXray is not a retailer and does not sell products directly.

MacroXray logoMACROXRAY

Your Protein. Your Rules. Ranked. We rank based on published nutrition data — no sponsored rankings, no mystery grades. Just numbers.

Featured onBoworaMacroXray - Featured on Startup Fame

Product

  • Optimize
  • Crave
  • Benchmark
  • Products
  • Articles
  • Brands

Categories

  • Protein Powder
  • Clear Protein
  • RTD Shake
  • Protein Bar
  • Protein Crisps
  • Sweet Snack
  • Savoury Snack
  • Smoothie
  • Cooking Mix
  • Fresh & Chilled
  • Other

Company

  • About
  • Methodology
  • FAQ
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us
© 2026 MacroXray. All rights reserved.
Text size
Some links are affiliate links. Affiliate disclosure
Quest Nutrition Overload Protein Bar, Cookie Commotion
Quest NutritionOverload Protein Bar, Cookie CommotionProtein Bar · Sweet · Milk Blend · #123 of 433 Protein Bars
Gluten-FreeVegetarianKosher
XRay Score
66/100
Weighted across
5 dimensions
Protein Efficiency10.0 g/100kcalValue for Money5.5 g/$Leanness2.2:1 P:FLow Carb17.2g net/100gFiber19.0 g/100g
This productProtein Bar avg
Nutrition
/ serving 58g/ 100g
Calories200 kcal345 kcal
Protein20g34g
Fat9.0g16g
Carbs (total)21g36g
Fiber11g19g
Sugar1.0g1.7g
Macro Split
200kcal/svg
Protein
33%
Fat
33%
Carbs
34%
Protein Bar Rankings
Value
Rank
Protein Efficiency
10.0 g/100kcal
#76/433
Value for Money
5.5 g/$
#271/401
Leanness
2.2:1 P:F
#166/419
Low Carb
17.2g net/100g
#55/379
Fiber
19.0 g/100g
#64/366
MacroXray logoMACROXRAY
Generated on Jun 9, 2026 bymacroxray.com
YOUR PROTEIN.YOUR RULES. RANKED.
Buy Now